
In one line: no Act fixes how long a warning lasts - your disciplinary code does - so write the validity period on every warning (commonly 6 months for a written warning and 12 months for a final one), give the employee a chance to respond first, and only rely on a warning while it is still valid.
Warnings are the everyday tool of discipline in a small business. Used well, they correct behaviour without anyone losing a job. Used carelessly - no dates, no chance to respond, no record - they collapse the moment a dismissal reaches the CCMA, because the employer cannot show that the employee knew where things stood.
The ladder: verbal, written, final written
- Progressive discipline is the default. The Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, which took effect on 4 September 2025, keeps the long-standing idea that discipline should correct behaviour, with warnings that grow more serious for repeated misconduct.
- A verbal warning is for a first, minor lapse. Record it in a dated note on the employee file even though it is "verbal".
- A written warning follows a repeat, or a first offence that is more than trivial.
- A final written warning tells the employee plainly that a further similar offence while it is valid may lead to dismissal.
- Serious misconduct can skip the ladder. Theft, assault or gross dishonesty may justify dismissal on a first offence, after a fair hearing. Warnings are not a precondition for every dismissal.
How long a warning stays valid
- Neither the Labour Relations Act nor the Basic Conditions of Employment Act sets a period. It comes from your disciplinary code, your contracts, or a collective agreement if you have one.
- Common practice in South African codes is about 3 months for a verbal warning, 6 months for a written warning and 12 months for a final written warning.
- Write the expiry date on the warning itself. "Valid for 6 months, until 16 May 2027" removes any argument about when it lapsed.
- Be consistent. If one employee's written warning lasts 6 months, another's should not quietly last 12 for the same kind of offence.
Not verified: the 3/6/12-month periods are a widely used convention, not a legal rule we could confirm in the Code of Good Practice. If you have no code, adopt one in writing and apply it to everyone.
What an expired warning still means
- Once a warning lapses, do not use it to move the employee up the ladder. A new offence after expiry starts from the appropriate step for that offence on its own.
- It stays on the file as history. Keep the record; just do not rely on it as an active warning for a sanction.
- "Similar" offences matter. A final warning for late-coming does not automatically support dismissal for a first incident of rudeness. Many codes limit a warning to the same or a related type of misconduct - say so in yours.
Issuing a warning fairly
- Find out what happened before deciding. Speak to the employee and anyone who saw it.
- Meet the employee and put the concern to them. A full formal hearing is not usually needed for a warning, but the employee should get a real chance to give their side.
- Decide, then write the warning: the date, what the employee did, the rule or standard broken, the level of warning, how long it is valid, what is expected from now on, and what may happen if it happens again.
- Give a copy to the employee and ask for a signature acknowledging receipt - not agreement.
- If the employee refuses to sign, have a witness sign that the warning was handed over, and note the refusal. A refusal does not cancel the warning.
- Let the employee add a written response. Attach it to the warning on file.
Can the employee challenge a warning?
- Yes. Section 186(2)(b) of the Labour Relations Act lists unfair disciplinary action short of dismissal as an unfair labour practice. A warning given without reason or without a chance to respond can be challenged.
- The employee has 90 days from the act, or from becoming aware of it, to refer an unfair labour practice dispute to the CCMA or a bargaining council (section 191(1)(b)(ii)).
- Disputes about warnings alone are uncommon, but the warning will be examined closely if it is later used to justify a dismissal. Our guide on what to do when a CCMA referral arrives covers the next step.
A worked timeline
- 3 February: an employee arrives more than an hour late without explanation for the third time in a month. After a short meeting, a written warning is issued, valid for 6 months, to 3 August.
- 10 June: late again, with no good reason. Because the written warning is still valid, a final written warning is issued, valid 12 months, to 10 June next year.
- September: another unexplained late arrival. A disciplinary hearing is held; dismissal is now a possible outcome, though the chairperson still weighs the explanation and the record.
- If the June lateness had happened on 10 August instead, the first warning would have expired, and the right step would have been a new written warning, not a final one.
Common mistakes
- No expiry date on the warning, leaving the period open to argument.
- "Final" warnings for a first minor lapse. The sanction should fit the offence.
- Relying on an expired warning to justify dismissal.
- A warning issued by email with no conversation first.
- Treating a refusal to sign as a refusal of the warning.
In SAHR, each warning and the employee's response sit on the employee file under discipline, and the Letters section keeps a copy of the warning you issued, so the dates and expiry are in one place if you later need them.
Sources
- Code of Good Practice: Dismissal (effective 4 September 2025) - DLA Piper, 11 September 2025.
- Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995, section 186(2)(b) (unfair disciplinary action short of dismissal) and section 191(1)(b)(ii) (90-day referral period) - gov.za.
- Unfair labour practice referrals - CCMA.
This is general information, not legal advice. Where a decision matters - a dismissal, a dispute, a CCMA referral - consult a labour law professional.