
In one line: a CCMA referral is the start of a process, not a judgment - check the dates and the forum, diarise the hearing, gather your documents, decide in advance what you would settle for, and never simply stay away.
For a small business, the first CCMA referral usually arrives as an email or a courier envelope with a form attached: your former employee says the dismissal was unfair. It is easy to feel ambushed, and easy to make one of two mistakes - ignore it because "they have no case", or panic and pay whatever is asked.
Neither is necessary. The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) runs a fixed, fairly predictable process set out in the Labour Relations Act (LRA) and the CCMA Rules. This guide walks through it from the employer's side: what the time limits are, how conciliation works, what happens if it fails, what to bring, and what it can cost you.

What you have received
- The referral form is usually the LRA Form 7.11, "Referral of a dispute to the CCMA for conciliation". It names the parties, the type of dispute, the date of dismissal and the outcome the employee wants (reinstatement, compensation or both).
- The employee must serve a copy on you. Section 191(3) of the LRA requires the referring party to satisfy the CCMA that a copy was served on the other party. That is why you often get the form before the CCMA contacts you.
- A notice of set-down follows from the CCMA with the date, time and venue (or online link) of the conciliation hearing. That is the document to diarise.
- It is not a finding against you. Nobody has yet decided whether the dismissal was fair. The CCMA has simply opened a case.
Step 1: check the dates
Time limits are the first thing a commissioner looks at, so look at them first too.
- Unfair dismissal: 30 days. Under section 191(1)(b)(i), the employee must refer the dispute within 30 days of the date of dismissal, or, if later, the date on which you made a final decision to dismiss or uphold the dismissal (for example after an internal appeal).
- Unfair labour practice: 90 days. Disputes about promotion, demotion, probation, training, benefits or suspension must be referred within 90 days of the act or omission, or of the date the employee became aware of it (section 191(1)(b)(ii)).
- Unfair discrimination under the Employment Equity Act: six months. These go to the CCMA under section 10 of that Act.
- A late referral is not automatically dead. The employee can apply for condonation, and the CCMA may allow a late referral on good cause shown (section 191(2)). The commissioner will look at how late, why, the prospects of success and prejudice to you.
What to do: work out the exact date of dismissal from your own records - the date on the dismissal letter, or the last day if notice was worked. If the referral looks late and there is no condonation application, say so at the hearing. If there is a condonation application, you are entitled to oppose it in writing.
Step 2: check it is the right forum
- If a bargaining council covers your sector, the dispute belongs there, not at the CCMA. Section 191(1)(a) sends dismissal disputes to the council with jurisdiction, and only to the CCMA where no council has jurisdiction. Many small businesses in motor, hospitality, clothing, construction, security and similar sectors fall under a council.
- Raise jurisdiction at the start of the hearing. If you believe the CCMA has no jurisdiction - a council covers you, the person was never your employee, there was no dismissal (for example a genuine resignation) - say so clearly and bring the proof. The commissioner may decide the point first.
- Was it really a dismissal? Section 186(1) lists what counts, including not renewing a fixed-term contract when the employee reasonably expected renewal, and constructive dismissal (the employee resigned because you made continued work intolerable). If the employee is alleging one of these, the employee must first prove that a dismissal happened.
Step 3: understand conciliation
Almost every dispute starts with conciliation. This is a meeting, not a trial.
- The CCMA must try to resolve the dispute within 30 days of the referral (section 135(2)). The parties may agree to extend that period.
- A commissioner tries to help you settle. Section 135(3) lets the commissioner mediate, make enquiries, and make a recommendation. Nobody gives evidence under oath and nobody "wins".
- What is said is without prejudice. Offers made in conciliation cannot be used later in arbitration as an admission. That is what lets both sides speak openly. A commissioner who conciliated also may not arbitrate the same dispute if a party objects (section 136(3)).
- It is often short. Many conciliations take an hour or two. The commissioner will often speak to each side separately (a "caucus") to test settlement figures.
- It ends one of two ways: a signed settlement agreement, or a certificate of outcome saying the dispute remains unresolved.
Con-arb: when conciliation and arbitration happen on the same day
- Con-arb means the commissioner moves straight to arbitration if conciliation fails, at the same sitting (section 191(5A)).
- It is compulsory for a dismissal during probation and for certain unfair labour practice disputes about probation.
- For most other dismissal disputes, the CCMA may schedule con-arb unless a party objects in writing in time. The CCMA Rules set a notice period for the objection before the hearing date. Check the set-down notice - if it says "con-arb", come ready to give evidence that day, with your witnesses.
Check the current CCMA Rules: the exact period for objecting to con-arb (commonly cited as seven days before the hearing) and which disputes are excluded should be confirmed against the CCMA Rules in force on the date of your hearing.
Who may represent you
- At conciliation, no lawyers. Under the CCMA Rules, a party may appear in person, or be represented by a director or employee of the business, or by a member, office-bearer or official of a registered employers' organisation the business belongs to. An attorney or advocate may not represent you at conciliation.
- At arbitration of a misconduct or incapacity dismissal, lawyers are usually excluded too - unless the commissioner and all parties agree, or the commissioner decides it would be unreasonable to expect a party to manage without one, considering the complexity, public interest and the comparative ability of the parties.
- For other disputes at arbitration, legal representation is generally allowed.
- A sole proprietor appears personally. A company or close corporation sends a director, member or an employee with a written authority to act and, ideally, to settle.
Verify before the hearing: the representation rules sit in the CCMA Rules (Rule 25 in the 2015 Rules as amended). Check the current version and, if you want a lawyer at arbitration, apply for it at the start.
Step 4: decide your settlement position before you arrive
Most CCMA cases settle at conciliation, and the decision whether to settle is the most important one you will make.
- Be honest about your process. Read our guides on poor performance dismissals and abscondment. If there was no hearing, no warning or no chance to respond, a procedural finding against you is likely even if the reason was good.
- Know the ceiling. Compensation for an ordinary unfair dismissal is capped at 12 months' remuneration (section 194(1)). For an automatically unfair dismissal (for example for pregnancy, union membership or discrimination) the cap is 24 months (section 194(3)). For an unfair labour practice, 12 months (section 194(4)). Commissioners award what is "just and equitable", which is usually well below the cap, especially for a procedural flaw only.
- Know the main remedy. Reinstatement is the primary remedy in section 193 - the employee goes back to work as if never dismissed, with back pay. It is refused mainly where the employee does not want it, a continued relationship would be intolerable, it is not reasonably practicable, or the only flaw was procedural (section 193(2)).
- Price the alternative. Arbitration means a second day away from the business, preparing witnesses and documents, and the risk of an award. A modest settlement can be cheaper than winning.
- Give your representative a mandate in writing - a figure you are willing to go up to - so the conciliation does not stall while someone phones the owner.
- Settle on terms, not only a number. Common terms: a payment "in full and final settlement" of the dispute, a payment date, a certificate of service, the reason recorded as a resignation or mutual separation where both agree, and confidentiality.
Paying a settlement amount is not an admission that the dismissal was unfair, unless the agreement says so. Make sure it does not.
What to bring to the hearing
Bring three copies of everything - one for you, one for the commissioner, one for the employee. Put them in a bundle with page numbers.
- The referral form and the set-down notice.
- The employment contract and any job description or written standards.
- The workplace rules or disciplinary code the employee was told about, with proof they knew (a signed acknowledgement, an induction checklist, a staff notice).
- The disciplinary record: warnings, the notice to attend a hearing, the minutes or notes of the hearing, the outcome letter and any appeal.
- The evidence of the reason: attendance registers, stock counts, CCTV stills, emails or messages, performance reviews and support plans.
- Payslips for the last three months, so the commissioner can see the remuneration on which any compensation would be calculated.
- Proof of final pay: notice pay, leave pay-out, any severance, the UI-19 and certificate of service. See our UIF guide for employers.
- A short written timeline - dates of each incident, warning, meeting and the dismissal. One page is plenty.
- Names and contact details of witnesses. At conciliation they are not usually needed, but at con-arb or arbitration they are.
- A company resolution or letter of authority for whoever represents the business, and your settlement mandate.
On the day
- Arrive early, or log in early if the hearing is online. The CCMA holds many hearings virtually; the set-down notice says which.
- Bring an ID and the case number from the notice.
- Stay calm and factual. The commissioner will ask each side to summarise the dispute. Keep yours to two or three minutes: what happened, what process you followed, and why you think it was fair.
- Listen to the commissioner's view. If the commissioner thinks your process was weak, it is a free preview of how an arbitrator may see it.
- Read any settlement agreement before you sign it, check the amount, payment date and "full and final" wording, and keep a signed copy.
If you do not attend
- At conciliation, the commissioner can simply issue a certificate that the dispute is unresolved, which lets the employee go straight to arbitration. You lose the chance to settle cheaply.
- At arbitration, the commissioner may continue without you (section 138(5)(b)), hear only the employee's evidence and make a default award.
- A default award can be rescinded - set aside - if it was made in your absence and you had a good reason for not being there (section 144). Apply promptly with proof, for example a medical certificate or evidence that the notice never reached you.
- If you genuinely cannot attend, ask for a postponement in writing as early as possible, with reasons, and copy the employee. A postponement is not guaranteed.
Check the deadline: the CCMA Rules set a time limit for applying to rescind an award, counted from when you learned of it (commonly cited as 14 days). Confirm the current rule before relying on it.
If conciliation fails: arbitration or the Labour Court
- The employee must ask for arbitration within 90 days of the certificate of outcome (section 136(1)), using LRA Form 7.13. Late requests need condonation.
- Most dismissal disputes for misconduct or incapacity go to CCMA arbitration (section 191(5)(a)). Some, such as automatically unfair dismissals and most large-scale operational requirements dismissals, go to the Labour Court instead (section 191(5)(b)).
- Arbitration is a hearing with evidence. Witnesses testify and are cross-examined. In a dismissal dispute, once the employee proves there was a dismissal, the employer must prove the dismissal was fair (section 192). Bring your witnesses.
- The commissioner must issue a signed award with brief reasons within 14 days of the end of the proceedings (section 138(7)).
- The award is final and binding (section 143) and, once certified, can be enforced like a court order. There is no appeal.
- A review to the Labour Court is possible but narrow - on grounds such as misconduct by the commissioner, a gross irregularity or exceeding powers - and must be brought within six weeks of the award (section 145). A review is not a second chance to argue the facts.
Costs
- The CCMA charges no fee to either party.
- Costs orders are the exception. An arbitrator may order costs in line with the law and fairness (section 138(10)), usually where a party behaved frivolously or vexatiously.
- The real cost is time - yours and your witnesses' - and any representative you pay for.
A worked example
A bakery with six staff dismisses a counter assistant on 3 November after a disciplinary hearing for repeated late-coming. The assistant refers an unfair dismissal dispute on 24 November.
- The referral is in time: 21 days after the dismissal, inside the 30-day window.
- No bargaining council covers the bakery, so the CCMA has jurisdiction.
- Conciliation should take place by about 24 December, 30 days after the referral, unless both parties agree to extend.
- The owner reviews the file: two written warnings, a hearing with notice and a chance to respond, an outcome letter. The process is sound, so the owner sets a low settlement mandate - perhaps a few weeks' pay - to avoid a day at arbitration, and is ready to walk away.
- If it does not settle, the assistant has 90 days from the certificate to request arbitration, and the bakery should be ready to call the supervisor who recorded the late-coming.
Illustration only: this example shows how the dates count. Whether a dismissal was fair depends on the facts, the workplace rules and the process followed in each case.
The mistakes that cost employers most
- Ignoring the notice and ending up with a default award.
- Arguing the merits at conciliation instead of using it to settle or to learn the employee's real complaint.
- Arriving without the disciplinary record. At arbitration the burden is on you; a story without documents is weak.
- Sending someone without authority, so a reasonable settlement cannot be accepted on the day.
- Not paying final pay that was owed anyway. Unpaid leave or notice pay invites a second claim and colours the whole dispute.
- Missing the bargaining council point - or raising it only at arbitration.
- Not paying a settlement on time. A settlement agreement can be made an award (section 142A) and enforced.
Common questions
- Must you reply to the referral in writing? At conciliation there is usually no formal written reply. Your answer is given at the hearing. If the employee has applied for condonation of a late referral, though, file a written opposition by the date the CCMA sets.
- Can you contact the employee to settle before the hearing? Yes. A settlement can be reached at any time. Put it in writing, signed by both, and tell the CCMA the case has settled so the hearing can be withdrawn. Keep the tone respectful and never pressure the employee.
- The employee was a contractor, not an employee. Raise it as a jurisdiction point. The CCMA will look at the reality of the relationship - control, hours, integration into the business, economic dependence - not only the label in the contract. Section 200A of the LRA presumes that a person earning below the earnings threshold is an employee if certain factors are present.
- The employee resigned. Bring the resignation letter or message. If the employee claims constructive dismissal, the employee must show that you made continued work intolerable; you then answer that evidence.
- Can you take a staff member as a witness? Yes, at arbitration. Ask them in good time, and do not tell them what to say. If a witness will not come voluntarily, the CCMA can issue a subpoena.
- Does a settlement count as income for tax? Settlement payments for loss of employment are generally taxable in the employee's hands and may require a tax directive. Ask your payroll provider or tax practitioner before paying.
Before the next dispute
- Write things down at the time: each warning, each meeting, each response.
- Give a hearing before any dismissal, even a short and informal one in a small business. The Code of Good Practice: Dismissal (in force from 4 September 2025) allows simpler processes for small employers, but not none.
- Use written warnings properly. They are the evidence of progressive discipline an arbitrator looks for.
- Issue the certificate of service and the UI-19 on the last day.
In SAHR, notes and letters sit on the employee file, and the Letters section keeps a copy of each warning and outcome letter you issued, so the bundle for a CCMA hearing can be put together from one place.
Sources
- Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 - sections 135, 136, 138, 142A, 143, 144, 145, 186, 191, 192, 193 and 194 - gov.za; Department of Employment and Labour (consolidated text)
- CCMA Rules (2015, as amended) - representation, con-arb objections, rescission and postponement - CCMA
- LRA Forms 7.11 (referral for conciliation) and 7.13 (request for arbitration) - CCMA
- Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998, section 10 (unfair discrimination referrals) - gov.za
- Code of Good Practice: Dismissal (effective 4 September 2025) - DLA Piper, 11 September 2025
This is general information, not legal advice. Where a decision matters - a dismissal, a dispute, a CCMA referral - consult a labour law professional.