SAHR blog

Retrenchment in a small business: the section 189 consultation steps and severance pay

18 November 2026 · 7 min read

Photo by Design by Matt on StockSnap (CC0)

In one line: start consulting while retrenchment is still only a possibility, put the reasons, alternatives, numbers, selection method and proposed severance in writing (LRA s189(3)), genuinely consider the answers, select fairly, and pay at least one week's remuneration for every completed year of service (BCEA s41) on top of notice and leave pay.

Retrenchment - dismissal for the employer's "operational requirements" - is the one kind of dismissal where the employee has done nothing wrong. That is why the Labour Relations Act puts the weight on process. A business can have a perfectly good reason to cut a post and still lose at the CCMA or Labour Court because the decision was made first and the "consultation" came afterwards.

This guide covers the ordinary procedure in section 189, which is the one that applies to most small businesses. The extra rules for large-scale retrenchments in section 189A only apply to employers with more than 50 employees.

What counts as an operational reason

  • Economic, technological, structural or similar needs of the employer. That is the definition in the LRA and repeated in BCEA s41(1). Falling turnover, losing a major client, new equipment that replaces a task, or merging two roles all qualify.
  • It is not a way around discipline or poor performance. If the real reason is the employee's conduct or work, use that procedure instead - see our guide to poor performance dismissal. A retrenchment that targets one "difficult" employee is a classic unfair dismissal.
  • The reason must be real and you must be able to show it. Keep the management accounts, the lost contract or the restructuring plan that drove the decision.

Step 1: start when you only contemplate it

  • Section 189(1) is triggered when you "contemplate" dismissing for operational reasons - not once you have decided. Consultation is meant to be able to change the outcome.
  • Who you consult with, in order: anyone a collective agreement says you must consult; otherwise a workplace forum; otherwise a registered trade union whose members are likely to be affected; otherwise the employees likely to be affected, or representatives they nominate.
  • In most small businesses with no union, that means the affected employees themselves. Speak to each one; do not consult only the person you have already earmarked.

Step 2: the written notice - section 189(3)

Invite the other side to consult in writing and disclose all relevant information. The Act lists what the notice must cover:

  1. The reasons for the proposed dismissals.
  2. The alternatives you considered before proposing dismissal, and why each was rejected.
  3. How many employees are likely to be affected and their job categories.
  4. The proposed method for selecting who is dismissed.
  5. When the dismissals are likely to take effect.
  6. The severance pay proposed.
  7. Any assistance you propose, such as time off to look for work or a reference.
  8. The possibility of future re-employment.
  9. How many people you employ in total.
  10. How many you have dismissed for operational reasons in the last 12 months.

Date the notice, hand a copy to each person consulted, and keep proof of delivery.

Step 3: consult for real

  • The goal is a "meaningful joint consensus-seeking process" (s189(2)) on three things: ways to avoid or reduce the dismissals or soften their effect, the selection method, and severance pay.
  • Alternatives worth putting on the table: short time, cutting overtime, a pay freeze, moving the employee to another vacant post, voluntary early departure, or delaying the date.
  • Give the employees a real chance to make representations (s189(5)), and consider and respond to them (s189(6)). If you disagree with a written proposal, reply in writing with your reasons.
  • Hold more than one meeting and keep minutes of each, signed or at least sent to the employees afterwards.

Not verified: the Act sets no minimum consultation period for section 189 retrenchments. Many practitioners treat two to four weeks as a reasonable minimum for a small business; we could not confirm a fixed figure in the Act or the current Code of Good Practice. The 60-day period applies only to section 189A.

Step 4: select fairly

  • Use criteria that were agreed, or that are fair and objective (s189(7)).
  • "Last in, first out" (LIFO) within the affected job category is the most commonly used objective criterion. Skills the business genuinely needs to keep can be a valid exception if you explain it.
  • Avoid criteria that hide a personal choice, such as "attitude" or "fit".
  • Never select on a discriminatory or protected ground - pregnancy, race, age, HIV status, union membership and the other grounds in LRA s187 and the Employment Equity Act. That makes the dismissal automatically unfair.

Step 5: give notice and pay out

  • Notice under BCEA s37(1): one week if employed six months or less, two weeks if more than six months but not more than a year, and four weeks after a year (or for a farm worker or domestic worker employed more than six months). A contract may give more.
  • Severance pay under BCEA s41(2): at least one week's remuneration for each completed year of continuous service, calculated under s35. Four years and ten months of service = at least four weeks' pay.
  • Severance is a minimum, not the whole final pay. Section 41(5) says it does not affect any other amount due, so add notice pay (or the notice worked), accrued annual leave and any earned bonus or commission.
  • An employee who unreasonably refuses an offer of alternative employment loses the right to severance pay (s41(4)). The test is whether refusing was reasonable - a much lower salary or a move to another city may make refusal reasonable.
  • Hand over the paperwork: a certificate of service (BCEA s42) and the UI-19 so the employee can claim UIF. See our UIF guide for employers.

Not verified: part of a severance payment may qualify for the SARS tax-free retirement lump-sum treatment when it is paid because of retrenchment. Confirm the current rules and limits with SARS or your payroll provider before calculating PAYE on it.

A worked timeline

  • 2 February: a small printing business loses its biggest client and starts looking at cutting one of three finishing posts.
  • 4 February: a section 189(3) notice goes to all three finishers, proposing one retrenchment, LIFO as the selection method, and severance at the BCEA minimum.
  • 9 and 16 February: two consultation meetings. One employee proposes a four-day week for everyone. The employer considers it, costs it, and replies in writing explaining why it would not cover the shortfall.
  • 20 February: the most recently appointed finisher (two years and three months' service) is given four weeks' notice.
  • 20 March: last day. Final pay includes two weeks' severance (two completed years), leave pay-out and the certificate of service and UI-19.

If the employee disputes it

  • An unfair dismissal dispute must be referred within 30 days of the dismissal (LRA s191(1)(b)(i)). What to do then is in our guide to a CCMA referral arriving.
  • A dispute only about the amount of severance pay goes to a bargaining council or the CCMA for conciliation and then arbitration (BCEA s41(6)-(9)).
  • Your best evidence is the paper trail: the s189(3) notice, minutes, the employees' proposals and your written answers, and the selection criteria applied.

Not verified: where a single employee is retrenched after a consultation that applied only to that employee, LRA s191(12) is generally read as letting the employee choose arbitration or the Labour Court. Check the current wording of the Act before relying on this.

Common mistakes

  • Announcing the decision and calling it consultation.
  • No written s189(3) notice, or one that leaves out the alternatives considered.
  • Retrenching one employee and advertising the same post a month later.
  • Paying severance instead of notice and leave, rather than on top of them.
  • Selecting by preference rather than by agreed or objective criteria.

In SAHR, the employee's leave balance is on the Leave page and the start date is on the employee file, which are the two figures you need for the leave pay-out and the completed years of service.

Sources

  • Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995, sections 189 (consultation, disclosure, selection), 189A (large employers) and 191 (referral periods) - gov.za.
  • Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997, section 41 (severance pay) - Acts Online; sections 37 (notice) and 42 (certificate of service) - gov.za.
  • Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998, section 6 (listed grounds) - gov.za.
  • Retrenchment and severance disputes - CCMA; Department of Employment and Labour - labour.gov.za.

This is general information, not legal advice. Where a decision matters - a dismissal, a dispute, a CCMA referral - consult a labour law professional.