
In one line: dismissing for poor performance is fair only if the standard was clear, the employee got a real chance and support to improve, and was heard before the decision - so write the standard down, record each step, and give time between them.
An employee who is not coping is one of the hardest problems in a small business. It is tempting to wait until patience runs out and then call a meeting to end the job. That is the route that most often ends at the CCMA with an unfair dismissal finding. A short, documented sequence is much safer and often fixes the problem on its own.
What changed in 2025
- A new Code of Good Practice: Dismissal took effect on 4 September 2025. It replaces the old Schedule 8 of the Labour Relations Act and the separate operational-requirements code.
- The core idea is unchanged. The employee should get a reasonable chance to improve, with guidance, training or counselling where suitable, and a chance to respond before dismissal.
- Small businesses get more flexibility. The Code says simpler, less formal processes may be appropriate for smaller employers. It does not remove the need for fairness.
- Incompatibility with the business culture is now treated under poor performance rather than being left out of the Code.
Not verified against the Code itself: these points come from law-firm summaries of the Code. Read the Gazette text before relying on a detail, especially for a live dismissal.
A sequence that holds up
- Define the standard. What is the job, what output or quality is expected, and by when? A vague "not good enough" is hard to defend.
- Check it was known. Was the employee told the standard, trained and given the tools? If not, start there.
- Hold an informal talk and note it. Describe the gap with examples and ask for the employee's view. A short note of the date and what was said is enough.
- Agree a support plan. Training, a mentor, clearer targets or a changed workload, with a review date.
- Review at the date. If there is progress, say so. If not, hold a formal meeting, put the shortfall in writing and set a final, realistic period.
- Hear the employee's response before any decision, and let the employee bring a colleague.
- Decide and confirm in writing. Consider alternatives such as a different role, and give the right to refer a dispute to the CCMA.
An example timeline
- Week 0: standard confirmed in writing; first talk.
- Weeks 1-8: support plan with a check-in every two weeks. The right length depends on the job - a few weeks for simple tasks, longer for complex work.
- Week 8: formal review meeting and written notice of the shortfall.
- Weeks 9-12: final improvement period with clear measures.
- Week 12: outcome meeting; employee heard before any decision.
Common mistakes
- Mixing performance and misconduct. Poor results from an employee who is trying are a capacity matter. Deliberate refusal to work is misconduct and follows a different route.
- Using probation as a shortcut. The Code confirms probation cannot be used to deny someone permanent employment.
- Moving the goalposts in the middle of the process.
- No record. Without dated notes, the CCMA has only the employee's version.
- Skipping the hearing because the employee "obviously" knows. For managers and senior staff the standard of warning may differ, but the chance to respond still applies.
In SAHR, notes, support plans and any letters sit on the employee file, and the Letters section keeps a copy of what you issued, so your record of each step is in one place if the CCMA asks for it.
Sources
- Code of Good Practice: Dismissal (effective 4 September 2025) - DLA Piper summary; DLA Piper, 11 September 2025.
- Changes for small businesses - Polity.
- Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995, section 188 (fair reason and fair procedure) - Department of Employment and Labour.
This is general information, not legal advice. Where a decision matters - a dismissal, a dispute, a CCMA referral - consult a labour law professional.