
In one line: no South African law makes you pay a year-end bonus, but once your contract promises one - or you have paid one in a way staff can reasonably rely on - taking it away can become a dispute, and the PAYE on whatever you pay is due with the December EMP201.
November is when small-business owners start working out whether there is money for a festive bonus this year - and when staff start asking about it. The two questions that cause trouble are the same every year: do I have to pay it? and why is the tax on it so high?
The starting point: the BCEA does not require a bonus
The Basic Conditions of Employment Act sets minimum hours, leave, notice and pay rules. It contains no obligation to pay a bonus or a 13th cheque. If you have never promised one, not paying one is not a breach of the Act.
That is where the simple part ends. Whether a bonus is owed depends on what you agreed and how you have behaved, not on the BCEA.
Guaranteed or discretionary: the distinction that decides everything
- A guaranteed 13th cheque - "an extra month's salary paid in December" written into the contract - is part of the employee's pay. You cannot simply decide not to pay it because the year was hard. Changing it is a change to terms and conditions, which needs the employee's agreement.
- A discretionary or performance bonus - "the company may pay a bonus depending on company and individual performance" - leaves the decision with you. You still have to apply it fairly and consistently.
- No wording at all is the risky middle. If you have paid the same bonus every December for years without saying it was discretionary, staff can argue it has become an implied term of employment.
Depends on the facts, not a fixed rule: whether a long-standing practice has become an implied contractual term is decided case by case by the CCMA and the courts. There is no number of years after which a bonus automatically becomes a right.
Where the CCMA comes in
Section 186(2)(a) of the Labour Relations Act lists, as an unfair labour practice, unfair conduct by the employer relating to "the provision of benefits to an employee". An employee who believes a bonus was unfairly withheld - for example, paid to everyone in the team except one person, with no reason - can refer that to the CCMA.
- The deadline: an unfair labour practice dispute must be referred within 90 days of the act or omission, or of the date the employee became aware of it (LRA section 191(1)(b)(ii)).
- A guaranteed bonus that is simply not paid is usually argued as a contractual claim for money owed, rather than an unfair labour practice.
Summarised, not quoted: the Labour Appeal Court in Apollo Tyres South Africa v CCMA (2013) is widely cited for the view that "benefits" can include advantages the employer grants under a policy or practice, even where the employer has a discretion. We have not re-checked the full judgment for this post - if a bonus dispute is likely, consult a labour law professional.
Leavers, new starters and people on notice
This is where most bonus arguments actually start. The BCEA says nothing about it, so the wording of your contract or bonus policy decides:
- "Must be in service on the payment date" - a common condition. An employee who resigns in October then has no claim, if the condition was clearly agreed in advance.
- Pro rata - many guaranteed 13th cheques are paid in proportion to the months worked in the year, both for new starters and for leavers. If you intend this, write it down.
- Serving notice in December - unless your policy excludes people on notice, an employee working out notice on the payment date is still in service.
If the policy is silent, expect the employee to argue for the most generous reading.
How PAYE works on a bonus
A bonus is remuneration, so employees' tax (PAYE) is withheld when you pay it. It is treated as an irregular, once-off payment, which is why the deduction looks so large on the December payslip.
In outline, payroll systems work out the tax on a bonus by difference:
- Work out the annual tax on the employee's regular annual pay.
- Work out the annual tax on regular annual pay plus the bonus.
- The difference is the PAYE withheld from the bonus - all in the month it is paid.
Because the whole bonus is taxed at the employee's top marginal rate, the take-home amount surprises people every year. Telling staff in advance, with an estimate, avoids most of the complaints. CalcSA's free bonus tax calculator gives an estimate for one employee.
Check against SARS: the method above is how SARS's employer guidance on annual payments is generally described by payroll providers; we have not quoted the current SARS Guide for Employers in respect of Employees' Tax directly here. Your payroll software applies it for you - confirm UIF and SDL treatment of the bonus with your payroll provider too.
Paying it on time
- The PAYE on a December bonus is declared and paid on the EMP201 for December, due by 7 January 2027 (the 7th of the following month, or the last business day before it if the 7th falls on a weekend or public holiday) - see SARS: Pay-As-You-Earn.
- Closing for December? If the bonus goes out with leave pay before a shutdown, plan the cash for both. Our post on December shutdowns and annual leave covers when leave pay is due.
A five-line bonus policy that prevents most disputes
- Type: guaranteed 13th cheque, or discretionary bonus - say which.
- Who qualifies: minimum service, and whether people on notice are included.
- Pro rata: yes or no, for starters and for leavers.
- Payment date and the "in service on that date" condition, if you use one.
- Discretion: for a discretionary bonus, the factors you will consider - and a line saying a past payment does not create a right to a future one.
Put it in the contract or a signed policy, and give it to new starters on day one - not in December.
Sources
- Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997 - gov.za (no bonus provision).
- Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995, sections 186(2)(a) and 191(1)(b)(ii) - gov.za.
- SARS, Pay-As-You-Earn and the EMP201 due date - sars.gov.za.
- Bonus tax method as described by payroll providers, e.g. SimplePay: annual bonus (secondary source).
- Bonus tax estimate - CalcSA bonus tax calculator.
This is general information, not legal advice. Where a decision matters - a dismissal, a dispute, a CCMA referral - consult a labour law professional.